Books about bookshops really seem to be all the rage these days and I can’t say I’m upset about that. So when I heard that Georgia Summers, an author whose debut novel The City of Stardust I really enjoyed, was releasing a dark fantasy novel about disappearing bookshops around London I was very excited to dig into it.
Our story opens by introducing us to Cassandra Fairfax, who we meet in a London luxury high-rise apartment, where she is meant to be appraising some rare magical books. Very quickly the situation turns bad and she barely manages to escape by drawing on some magical powers related to ink. Shortly after her escape we also learn that her previous mentor and magical bookshop owner Chiron has died and that it is her duty to take over the bookshop from him.
What follows is a lot of world building about a number of these secret magical bookshops that are all connected by a magical River, which we learn is unfortunately starting to dry up. This has a number of bad consequences, for instance when the magic river dries up at any particular magic bookshop, the bookshop disappears as though it never existed, killing its owner in the process. There is also eventually talk about paradox books which have the power to alter history and have already changed the world, but whose effects could also be reversed if the River goes away.
I think there are a lot of interesting ideas in the book, but I don’t think they were presented in particularly clear or compelling ways. Many of the key parts of the story are based on “reading” powers onto people through the use of magic inks. But how all of it works is incredibly hand-wavy and is always exactly whatever the plot calls for instead of trying to be consistent in any way.
I would be more than willing to overlook any quibbles I had with the magic system if the story had characters that I really connected with. Unfortunately, that wasn’t the case here. I found the protagonist Cassandra to be unlikable and I often wasn’t sure what her motivations were. Many times throughout the book, she and the people she cared about would be placed in grave mortal peril, survive, and then go about their lives for days or maybe weeks on end with no additional urgency to stop the threats from happening again, even though the people who were intent on doing them harm always knew where they lived. I would have even been ok if there was a throwaway line saying something to the effect that the bookshop wouldn’t let the villains into the store through some magical means, but that never happened either.
I don’t think this is a bad book, but between recently reading a few Brandon Sanderson novels and having such high expectations about this author, I was disappointed. If you are a big books-about-bookshops person, I think you’ll still find a lot to like in the book, but ultimately I think her debut novel is a much better read.

























